I would disagree with any blanket statement that managing separate records for DAFs at a sponsoring organization isn't useful. It may well vary based on the specific circumstances of your organization, and I have found it very useful for organizing this information.
We currently have almost a thousand DAFs linked to one sponsoring organization, with an order of magnitude more grants. Having the intermediate association with the specific DAF has proved helpful in understanding this information. Many of the DAFs are consistently associated with giving of one or two people, but other DAFs include giving from a shifting alignment of donors, and the DAF entities help in understanding that activity. If a donor lets us know informally that they're initiating a DAF grant, having the links to person to DAF help us keep an eye out for that distribution. Knowing that a donor has given through multiple DAFs, possibly at multiple sponsoring organizations, is a useful data point. Having the DAF name can help personalize donor acknowledgments (and perhaps whether that is "irrelevant" is open to discussion?). And so on.
There is overhead in managing this data, but it's quite modest, in my experience, and the data has proved useful.
We consistently hard-credit the sponsoring organization, so we have not found that having the additional DAF soft-credit complicates identifying the correct legal donor in any receipting or reporting.
If you don't find it useful to manage information on DAFs, by all means, don't. If you do find it useful to manage that information, that's perfectly reasonable, whatever else you may hear.
My US$0.02 worth; the usual disclaimers apply.
Good luck!
------------------------------
Alan S. Hejnal (he/him)
Smithsonian Institution
Washington DC
hejnala@si.edu------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 07-18-2025 08:18 AM
From: John Taylor
Subject: DAFs within a Community Foundation
I have seen some organizations create a record on their CRM for every individual fund maintained at a DAF. Not just community foundations but also Fidelity and the like. That is not useful and requires unnecessary data entry and record maintenance. Further, I know many donors maintain multiple "funds" at the same DAF; one for each partner and another for the couple. Why bother tracking which account they choose to use?
What is more important is knowing they have used a DAF to donate, and you give them recognition credit. It doesn't matter what the name of the fund is!
Looked at this differently, I have five different accounts at my primary bank. Some belong to me, some are joint, and several are investment accounts. The charities I give to don't create a record for each of these accounts. The legal donor is me in every case!
Since you do not issue any receipts for DAF gifts, it's not essential to track the name on individual funds. Your thank-you letter to the individual will still read the same: "Thank you for the grant you recommended through the DE Community Foundation." The fund name is irrelevant.
John
John H. Taylor, PrincipalJohn H. Taylor Consulting, LLC
2604 Sevier Street
Durham, NC 27705
919.816.5903 (cell/text)
Serving the Advancement Community Since 1987
Original Message:
Sent: 7/18/2025 8:50:00 AM
From: Bridget Everman
Subject: RE: DAFs within a Community Foundation
Thanks, John. That's what I've been doing. I was asked to do it differently, but I will stick to my guns.
Bridget
Bridget Gavaghan Everman
Database Manager
The Music School of Delaware
(302) 762-1132 ext. 280
Original Message:
Sent: 7/18/2025 8:26:00 AM
From: John Taylor
Subject: RE: DAFs within a Community Foundation
The legal donor is the DE Community Foundation. The XYZ fund is just the internal name on an account. It is not a legal entity.
As such (and some will disagree with me here), the hard credit goes on the DE Community Foundation. In my mind, the XYZ Fund isn't as crucial as the individual who recommended the grant. I would definitely soft-credit that individual.
Whether you want to also soft-credit the XYZ Fund is your call. To me, it's just extra work for your gift entry staff, and you can derive just as much recognition information from the soft-credit on the individual's record.
John
John H. Taylor, PrincipalJohn H. Taylor Consulting, LLC
2604 Sevier Street
Durham, NC 27705
919.816.5903 (cell/text)
Serving the Advancement Community Since 1987
Original Message:
Sent: 7/18/2025 8:11:00 AM
From: Bridget Everman
Subject: DAFs within a Community Foundation
Hello All,
I think I know the answer to this, but I'll ask anyway. Can I hard credit "The XYZ fund at the DE Community Foundation," or do I have to hard credit the Community Foundation and soft credit The XYZ Fund? The name on the check is DE Community Foundation.
Thanks,
Bridget
------------------------------
Bridget Everman
The Music School of Delaware
beverman@musicschoolofdelaware.org
------------------------------